LOVE IN MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING
From the beginning to the end to the end of the play, Love comes by means of two couples in this comedy: Claudio/Hero and Beatrice/Benedick.
Claudio/Hero story follows the normal romantic relationship between a young couple who fall in love since the start. However, Benedick/Beatrice work hard to give the impression that neither is a bit interested in the other.
We find a series of difficulties which attempt to destroy their love as in any comedy written by Shakespeare. The difference here is the incorporation of elements related more to Reality than Imagination or Fantasy.
We have to deal with jealousy, mistrust, false appearances, pride, vengeance and humiliation…all elements which try to destroy the love the characters want to achieve.
LOVE THROUGH THE CHARACTERS:
BEATRICE/BENEDICK
Beatrice does not represent the archetype imposed over women by the society of her time. She is not kind, polite, quite or submissive. She is cynical, witty and sharp instead. Her vision of love is not filled with fantasy or dreams, she knows what she wants out of the matrimony, which it is to be free to express herself and not be submitted to the will of a controlling husband.
Though she pictures herself as someone who cannot be controlled by love’s foolish effects, she demonstrates otherwise once she overhears her cousin Hero talking about how Benedick is in love with her. Then she opens herself to love. It’s easy to understand that her first attitude towards love was just a wall defense to the weakness love brings with it. She is just waiting for her perfect and equal partner. She rebels against the unequal status women have in the society.
Benidick on the other hand, is the perfect nemesis to Beatrice as he maintains the same attitude towards love: He will never get married.
But his attitude underlies a secret love for Beatrice, masked with a cold appearance and a competition full of insults. They tease and insult one another without mercy and deny that they will ever marry anyone. However, when he overhears his friends talking about Beatrice’s love for him, he declares his true feelings for her.
In my opinion, we can doubt about this change of direction regards his feelings, thinking that maybe he’s telling the truth about loving her for a long time or maybe he’s just fallen in love during the play.
However, after Claudio dismisses Hero, Beatrice asks Benedick to defend her cousin’s honor. At first he refuses because she’s asking him to betray his closest friend, but at the end, he accepts. This confirms his true feelings for Beatrice and the change of loyalty over her.
HERO/CLAUDIO
The one formed by Claudio and Hero represents the young, kind and love at first sight. They fall in love with each other fast and with the total conviction of their love. But this type of love so fast and unexpected always carries with it a lack of real trust and deep bond between a couple.
Claudio’s love is presented as something easy to break. He allows himself to be deceived by Don John not just once but twice throughout the story. Though he’s sure about his love for Hero, he doesn’t hesitate a second to believe she’s been unfaithful to him. Later he realizes his mistake and is willing to marry another woman in an effort to rectify his errors. Claudio is pictured as an immature boy who is always ready to believe in mere rumors. We don’t appreciate a significant change in his character during the play.
On the other hand, Hero is presented as the perfect archetype of the society of her time: She is polite, kind, sweet, submissive… she doesn’t take any role in conquering her lover; she just sits and waits for him to approach her. She is pictured as a passive character.
One example of his docility is when Claudio humiliates her in front of her family and she faints instead of defending herself. It is her cousin Beatrice who tries to defend her honor.
However, a little change in her character appears when she agrees to fake her death in order to get her innocence back. It is maybe a first move toward self-confidence and maturity.
Elements which accompany Love in this play:
- Setting: In this comedy, it’s not the addition of a new environment which helps the characters to get the happy ending. We appreciate more a psychological change in the characters nature during the play than a change in scenario.
- Separation and reunification: In this play, the couple who suffer the most is Hero and Claudio. Each time that he is deceived into believing something awful about his lover, he leaves her and then later returns. It’d be logic to think he would come back wiser but he seems to be ready to believe lies once again.
- Deception among characters: Deception here is one of the most important elements which interfere in Love’s path. Claudio is deceived twice by Don John provoking the breakup of the couple. However, Hero suffers the worst deception being her honor questioned by her partner.
- Mistaken identity: This comedy uses these mistakes to make clever twists in the story. The two main mistakes come by the hand of Don John, who uses the easily manipulated Claudio to make him believe first that Don Pedro wants Hero for himself and later that Hero has deceived him with another man.
- Difficulties: Hero and Claudio difficulties come from his immaturity and his weak personality. However in Beatrice and Benedick relationship, the main difficulty comes from their firm determination to not fall in love. Overhearing, plotting, and misunderstanding help to increase these difficulties.
- Tension between characters: It’s a common element in Shakespeare’s comedies the introduction of a jealous character who tries to destroy or manipulate love’s success. In Much ado about nothing is the character of Don John who, driven by jealousy and rage, attempts to sabotage Hero and Claudio relationship.
- Happy ending: There is no happy ending without marriages in it. This is seen as a consequence of the society of the time which contemplated marriage as the ultimate step in women’s lives. This comedy is no exception. No matter if women have been deceived, rejected or humiliated during the play, they seem happy to get married at the end.