Coversheet

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments

SECOND PAPER

Subject :# 14159 Curs Monográfic: Shakespeare through Performance

Student´s name: Gómez Aguilar, Raquel

Title of the paper: Love and Desire in Shakespeare’s comedies.

Author or topic: William Shakespeare

Abstract: This second paper is going to be focused on the analysis of Love as the central theme in Shakespeare’s comedies. I’ve made a selection of the three comedies that in my opinion offer the reader a type of love richer, more developed and surrounded by a series of elements which make it appropriated for a good analysis (A midsummer night’s dream, Much ado about nothing and The taming of the shrew). The paper is divided into three parts: First, there is an Introduction of how Love is presented in Shakespeare’s plays (mirroring his own society). Second, there is the Analysis of Love as the main theme (with its proper interpretation in the three chosen comedies) and finally there is the Conclusion.

Bibliography, URL’s

Auto-evaluation: 8

Academic year 2010/2011
© a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
© Raquel Gómez Aguilar
ragoa@alumni.uv.es

Bibliography

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments
  • Wikipedia contributors. “William Shakespeare.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 19 Sep. 2011. Web. 21 Nov. 2011.

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shakespeare>

  • Wikipedia contributors. «Shakespearean comedy.» Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 16 Nov. 2011. Web. 21 Nov. 2011.

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shakespearean_comedy>

  • Wikipedia contributors. «A Midsummer Night’s Dream.» Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 30 Nov. 2011. Web. 21 Nov. 2011

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Midsummer_Night%27s_Dream>

  • Wikipedia contributors. «Much Ado About Nothing.» Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 1 Dec. 2011. Web. 23 Nov. 2011.

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Much_Ado_About_Nothing>

  • Wikipedia contributors. «The Taming of the Shrew.» Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 21 Nov. 2011. Web. 26 Nov. 2011.

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Taming_of_the_Shrew>

  • SparkNotes Editors. “SparkNote on A Midsummer Night’s Dream.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2003. Web. 23 Sept. 2011. 21 Nov.2011

<http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/msnd/>

  • SparkNotes Editors. “SparkNote on Much Ado About Nothing.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2003. Web. 23 Sept. 2011. 25 Nov.2011

<http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/muchado/>

  • SparkNotes Editors. “SparkNote on The Taming Of The Shrew.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2003. Web. 23 Sept. 2011. 27 Nov.2011

<http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/shrew/>

  • Crowther, John, ed. “No Fear A Midsummer Night’s Dream.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2005. Web. 16 Nov. 2011. 18 Nov.2011

<http://nfs.sparknotes.com/msnd/>

  • Crowther, John, ed. “No Fear Much Ado About Nothing.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2005. Web. 16 Nov. 2011. 20 Nov.2011

<http://nfs.sparknotes.com/muchado/>

  • Crowther, John, ed. “No Fear The Taming of the Shrew.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2005. Web. 16 Nov. 2011. 25 Nov. 2011

<http://nfs.sparknotes.com/shrew/>

Conclusion

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments

CONCLUSION

I decided to analyze these four comedies written by William Shakespeare because in my opinion each one of them gives the reader the opportunity to learn and discover Love in a different way.

In As you like it, we found a brave heroine fighting for her love. Her main task in the story is to re-educate her partner in terms of loving in a more realistic way. She wants him to realize that real love is not about fantasies or dreams, but about accepting women with her virtues and faults.

In A midsummer night’s dream, Love and Magic coexist in the story. The fairies are responsible of showing how moody and volatile Love can be. Humans are treated as mere puppets and Love is seen as something unstable and easily influenced.

These two first comedies can be put in a group. They both share the addition of a new setting (the forest) which provides a different “world” where love is tested.

However, with Much ado about nothing and The taming of the shrew, Love’s perspective changes.

Shakespeare presents a type of love more focused on women’s role within the society and their duties as future wives. Love’s main difficulties come from the incorporation of cruel characters and economic and social differences.

They’re both more realistic plays mirroring the society of the time where women’s future was determined by the figures of the father and the husband.

Another important difference is that in the first comedies Shakespeare ends the story with the wedding ceremony, however in The taming of the shrew we get to see women’s lives within the marriage. This play takes a step forward in showing how a woman can be humiliated until she accepts her submissive role as a wife.

*** In my opinion, William Shakespeare is a master presenting Love in all its possible manifestations: Love at first sight, sweet and innocent love versus carnal love, love with jealousy, malevolence, cruelty or vengeance versus love with passion, obsession and dreams. Love conditioned by magic, family, society, money or politic issues. Love between characters disguised and even the presence of homoerotic feelings… All these manifestations of Love make William Shakespeare’s comedies a gift to the reader.

Love in the taming of the shrew

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments

LOVE IN THE TAMING OF THE SHREW

Love in this comedy is presented by means of the couples Bianca and Lucentio and Katherine and Petruchio.

Basically, we have two models of experiencing love. While Lucentio feels the love at first sight and fights to win Bianca’s heart, Petruchio’s intentions come with his need to marry a wealthy woman, no matter who that woman is.

Love in this comedy is focused on the women’s behavior towards the rules of the society and its imposed laws over them. We find the two opposite sides in the sisters Bianca and Katherine.

LOVE THROUGH THE CHARACTERS

  • BIANCA/LUCENTIO:

Bianca plays the perfect young maid role in this comedy: she is a lovely girl, sweet and willing to become what society expects from a woman: the perfect wife. Her main difficult comes from her father who, following society rules, wishes to marry his older daughter in first place.

Since Bianca is a popular woman desired by a few men, Love appears as something unbalanced for the main characters. Once she lets her heart speak, her choice is Lucentio who wins her love with his perseverance.

Lucentio represents the poetical view of love that Petruchio dismisses. He falls in love at first sight and says that he will die if he cannot win her heart, so he sets a romantic plan to do so.

Throughout the play Lucentio and Bianca’s relationship appears to be refreshing and pure in comparison to the relationship between Petruchio and Katherine. Petruchio’s decision to marry is based on his desire to win a fortune, while Lucentio’s is based on romantic love.

However, Shakespeare gives the reader an idea of what the marriage is going to mean for this couple, when playing the little game where every husband test his wife to know if she is dutiful or not and Bianca doesn’t act as he expects from her.  It seems as if his theatrical way of love is not enough to fight the problems a married life brings with it.

  • KATHERINE/PETRUCHIO

At the start of the story she is presented as a character full of decision, tempered and able to insult men around her. She is considered as an ill-tempered woman by the people around her. However it is said that this “false” attitude towards love and men in general, comes from her sadness and fear to not be able to win a husband and thus a place in society. It is important to remember that the ultimate purpose to women in life in that time was to get married and be a submissive and disciplined wife. Without a husband women had no identity by themselves.

So Katherine lives in a circle where she doesn’t get treated by men the way she needs to, so she gets angry, and the angrier she gets, the more she objects to fall in love.

The message the reader receives from this introduction is that the more a woman fits in society’s demands, the easier she’ll find love and a husband. People will enjoy her company and she will have a place in the world and an identity inside her circle.

So maybe Katherine comprehends that is better to submit to the husband’s demand than to be a “shrew” to the society, because at the end of the play she becomes the devoted and submissive wife every man wishes (the last scene where there is a game to discover which wife is the most obliging and Katherine surprises everyone being the winner is very significant, acting as a lesson)

On the other hand, Petruchio is a complex character. At the beginning of the play he is just a man looking for a woman to marry. Once he starts the task of getting Katherine as his wife with the idea of taming her after the wedding, we can interpret his attitude from two points of view. If we consider him as nothing more than a vain, uncaring and greedy man who treats marriage as an act of domination, then the play highlights a dark side strange to find in the genre of comedies, but If on the other hand, Petruchio is actually able of loving Katherine and conceives of taming her just as a way to achieve a happy marriage, then the play shows a purpose more acceptable behind the “taming”. Since Petruchio’s manners to achieve his goal are less than inhuman (he even keeps Katherine hungry for days) most people believe that the truth about his intentions lies somewhere in between.

-Elements that appear in this comedy along with Love:

  • Setting: If the addition of a new setting provides a place to accomplish the characters dreams in most of the comedies written by Shakespeare, in the taming of the shrew it means the domestication of Katherine. Once she is away from her home and the society she knows, she is capable to become someone else entirely.
  • Mistaken identity:  In this comedy, Bianca’s suitors disguise themselves in order to win her love.
  • Difficulties: This play introduces a new difficulty: the economic aspects of marriage (how economic circumstances determine who marries whom). Marriage appears as an economic transaction organized by the future husband and the father. For example, Lucentio wins Bianca’s heart but he is only able to marry her once he proves to her father to be rich. The main difficult to Katherine is the acceptance of her role in the marriage and the social obligations imposed for being a woman.
  • Happy ending:  The difference this play presents is that characters in the previous comedies would get their happiness through the realization of the wedding. However, in the case of Katherine and Petruchio their happy ending comes from her domestication, not from the wedding ceremony.

***The innovation that this comedy brings with Katherine and Petruchio is that the reader is able to see what happens after the wedding ceremony. With the roles of other feminine characters in Shakespeare’s plays, we have witnessed how some of them confront society’s or family’s rules and how they seek refuge in a new environment where they’re brave enough to act as freely as any man. But what happens after the wedding? It is seen that once a couple get the happy ending they come back to the city, palace or court where they belong. With this comedy we get to see the afterwards.

The taming of the shrew

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments

THE TAMING OF THE SHREW

The Taming of the Shrew is one of Shakespeare’s earliest comedies, and it shares many essential characteristics with his other romantic comedies, such as Much Ado About Nothing and A Midsummer Night’s Dream. These characteristics include light hearted humor, disguises and deception, and a happy ending in which most of the characters come out satisfied.

Sometimes this play is compared to Much ado about nothing, and although the plots themselves are not similar, each play gives us a pair of protagonists who enter into a battle of wits and insults.

The comedy focuses on courtship and marriage, but the principal difference with the other comedies written by Shakespeare; it is that the taming of the shrew gives a lot of attention to married life after the wedding. The other comedies usually conclude with the wedding ceremony itself.

If Shakespeare used part of his stories to picture scenes where women were free to speak for themselves and were free to be an active role in conquering love without the pressure of male domination. In this comedy Katherine in representation of women’s duties, is humiliated and forced to be submissive under her husband’s figure.

So the love we’re going to find in this comedy comes linked with marriage, duty, identity, family…etc. They are elements with great importance in the society of that time.

  • BRIEF SUMMARY:

The comedy tells the story of two sisters: Bianca and Katherine. While Bianca is sweet and wants to get married, Katherine is ill-tempered and with no wishes to become a wife. Lucentio’s character falls in love with Bianca and works to win her heart while Petruchio intends to “tame” Katherine into a submissive wife.

  • MAIN CHARACTERS:

Katherine:  The “shrew” of the play’s title, Katherine is quick-tempered and against anyone who tries to marry her.

Petruchio:  He’s a gentleman from Verona. Eccentric and quick-witted, he comes to Padua to get a wealthy wife.

Bianca: Bianca proves herself the opposite of her sister, Katherine, being sweet, polite and ready to find love and a husband.

Lucentio: A young student, he’s good-natured and intrepid. He falls in love with Bianca at first sight and disguises himself as a teacher to win her heart.

–> ANALYSIS OF LOVE IN THE TAMING OF THE SHREW

Love in Much ado about nothing

noviembre 30th, 2011 | SECOND PAPER (CURS MONOGRAFIC) | No comments

LOVE IN MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING

From the beginning to the end to the end of the play, Love comes by means of two couples in this comedy:  Claudio/Hero and Beatrice/Benedick.

Claudio/Hero story follows the normal romantic relationship between a young couple who fall in love since the start. However, Benedick/Beatrice work hard to give the impression that neither is a bit interested in the other.

We find a series of difficulties which attempt to destroy their love as in any comedy written by Shakespeare. The difference here is the incorporation of elements related more to Reality than Imagination or Fantasy.

We have to deal with jealousy, mistrust, false appearances, pride, vengeance and humiliation…all elements which try to destroy the love the characters want to achieve.

LOVE THROUGH THE CHARACTERS:

BEATRICE/BENEDICK

Beatrice does not represent the archetype imposed over women by the society of her time. She is not kind, polite, quite or submissive. She is cynical, witty and sharp instead. Her vision of love is not filled with fantasy or dreams, she knows what she wants out of the matrimony, which it is to be free to express herself and not be submitted to the will of a controlling husband.

Though she pictures herself as someone who cannot be controlled by love’s foolish effects, she demonstrates otherwise once she overhears her cousin Hero talking about how Benedick is in love with her. Then she opens herself to love. It’s easy to understand that her first attitude towards love was just a wall defense to the weakness love brings with it. She is just waiting for her perfect and equal partner. She rebels against the unequal status women have in the society.

Benidick on the other hand, is the perfect nemesis to Beatrice as he maintains the same attitude towards love: He will never get married.

But his attitude underlies a secret love for Beatrice, masked with a cold appearance and a competition full of insults. They tease and insult one another without mercy and deny that they will ever marry anyone. However, when he overhears his friends talking about Beatrice’s love for him, he declares his true feelings for her.

In my opinion, we can doubt about this change of direction regards his feelings, thinking that maybe he’s telling the truth about loving her for a long time or maybe he’s just fallen in love during the play.

However, after Claudio dismisses Hero, Beatrice asks Benedick to defend her cousin’s honor. At first he refuses because she’s asking him to betray his closest friend, but at the end, he accepts. This confirms his true feelings for Beatrice and the change of loyalty over her.

HERO/CLAUDIO

The one formed by Claudio and Hero represents the young, kind and love at first sight. They fall in love with each other fast and with the total conviction of their love.  But this type of love so fast and unexpected always carries with it a lack of real trust and deep bond between a couple.

Claudio’s love is presented as something easy to break. He allows himself to be deceived by Don John not just once but twice throughout the story. Though he’s sure about his love for Hero, he doesn’t hesitate a second to believe she’s been unfaithful to him.  Later he realizes his mistake and is willing to marry another woman in an effort to rectify his errors. Claudio is pictured as an immature boy who is always ready to believe in mere rumors. We don’t appreciate a significant change in his character during the play.

On the other hand, Hero is presented as the perfect archetype of the society of her time: She is polite, kind, sweet, submissive… she doesn’t take any role in conquering her lover; she just sits and waits for him to approach her.  She is pictured as a passive character.

One example of his docility is when Claudio humiliates her in front of her family and she faints instead of defending herself. It is her cousin Beatrice who tries to defend her honor.

However, a little change in her character appears when she agrees to fake her death in order to get her innocence back. It is maybe a first move toward self-confidence and maturity.

Elements which accompany Love in this play:

  • Setting:  In this comedy, it’s not the addition of a new environment which helps the characters to get the happy ending. We appreciate more a psychological change in the characters nature during the play than a change in scenario.
  • Separation and reunification:  In this play, the couple who suffer the most is Hero and Claudio. Each time that he is deceived into believing something awful about his lover, he leaves her and then later returns. It’d be logic to think he would come back wiser but he seems to be ready to believe lies once again.
  • Deception among characters: Deception here is one of the most important elements which interfere in Love’s path. Claudio is deceived twice by Don John provoking the breakup of the couple. However, Hero suffers the worst deception being her honor questioned by her partner.
  • Mistaken identity:  This comedy uses these mistakes to make clever twists in the story. The two main mistakes come by the hand of Don John, who uses the easily manipulated Claudio to make him believe first that Don Pedro wants Hero for himself and later that Hero has deceived him with another man.
  • Difficulties:  Hero and Claudio difficulties come from his immaturity and his weak personality. However in Beatrice and Benedick relationship, the main difficulty comes from their firm determination to not fall in love. Overhearing, plotting, and misunderstanding help to increase these difficulties.
  • Tension between characters:  It’s a common element in Shakespeare’s comedies the introduction of a jealous character who tries to destroy or manipulate love’s success. In Much ado about nothing is the character of Don John who, driven by jealousy and rage, attempts to sabotage Hero and Claudio relationship.
  • Happy ending:  There is no happy ending without marriages in it. This is seen as a consequence of the society of the time which contemplated marriage as the ultimate step in women’s lives. This comedy is no exception. No matter if women have been deceived, rejected or humiliated during the play, they seem happy to get married at the end.